The United Church of Canada is currently holding its 44th General Council, but this time it is a little different than past occasions. The current General Council is online and spread over several months. This should provide ample opportunity for discussion and reflection. A key item on the agenda of every General Council is the election of the next Moderator. In the United Church, the moderator is elected by the members of the General Council towards the end of the meeting. The new Moderator is installed in the office at the end of the meeting and then serves over the succeeding years until the next General Council meeting. The current 44th General Council is moderated by the Rev. Richard Bott, who was elected at the 43rd General Council in 2018 in Oshawa.
The plan for the Moderatorial election this year was that nominations would be received until June 17th. At that time, the slate of nominees would be announced and the discernment would begin. The election is July 23 and the installation is August 7. The surprise this year is that there is only one nominee. This is not unprecedented, but it is more common to have a large slate of candidates, up to a dozen or more. When nominations closed on June 17, there was a sole nominee: the Rev. Dr. Carmen Lansdowne. There is no process for acclamation, so there will be a ballot on July 23.
Biography of Carmen Lansdowne
Carmen Lansdowne is a member of the Heiltsuk First Nation, and a life-long member of The United Church of Canada (UCC). Baptized into the UCC in 1975, she waited until adulthood to make a profession of faith which came from a deep sense of personal spirituality and a callingto participate fully in the life and work of the church.
She attended the Vancouver School of Theology (VST) in the MDiv program from 2003-2007, and after successful completion of her internship at Marengo Pastoral Charge (Alsask & Loverna,SK), she was ordained to further study in 2007. She completed coursework for a ThM degree atVST in 2008, then moved to Berkeley, CA where she commenced coursework for a PhD at theGraduate Theological Union. She completed the ThM in 2011 and the PhD in 2016.
In addition to her theological contributions as a writer and speaker, Carmen has served the church in a variety of roles. From 2006-2013 she served on the Executive and CentralCommittees of the World Council of Churches, as well as being an ex-officio correspondingmember of the Executive of the UCC General Council. She continues to attend global theological andchurch gatherings by invitation. She has served on the Pension Board and the Theology, Interchurch-Interfaith Committee of the UCC, executive search committees for theGeneral Council Office and the World Council of Churches, and various subcommittees of boththe WCC and UCC. She served as one of six facilitators offering feedback from commissioners atGeneral Council 43. She currently chairs the Indigenous Candidacy Board of the United Churchand sits on the Keepers of the Vision of the Sandy Saulteaux Spiritual Centre. She also recentlyjoined the Board of Directors of the Vancouver Foundation – Canada’s largest communityfoundation. Carmen joined First United Church Community Ministry Society as Executive Director inFebruary 2017. Under her leadership, she has effected an organizational turnaround resulting inincreased capacity and stability. She has also shepherded to construction-phase a $65Mredevelopment of First United’s property in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside. The newpurpose-built facility will triple First United’s programming and ministry space and add 103 non-market rental units of Indigenous housing (to be operated by Lu’ma Native Housing Society).Under Carmen’s leadership, First United has developed strong labour relations with itsunionized staff, built a highly skilled and committed leadership team, increased revenues, andbecome a certified living wage employer. She worships at Lynn Valley United Church as she isable.
She continues to maintain academic interests through guest lectures and various writingprojects and as a Christ Institute Fellow with the Westar Institute. Carmen guest preaches atdifferent communities of faith several times a year, and remains committed to Indigenous ways of being, parenting and partnering. She lives in North Vancouver with her partner, two children, and their dog Cocoa.
A Statement of Vision
I am deeply humbled by the call to serve The United Church of Canada by letting my name stand for the role of Moderator. This call has come from a circle of friends, colleagues, mentorsand elders whom I deeply trust, and whose words of encouragement, caution, excitement andconcern I have sat with in prayer.
The role of Moderator is a permanent leadership position in our church in its current iteration, but one of the best things about our church is the fact that the leadership within the role is notpermanent. As such over time the church has benefited through the diverse backgrounds andgifts of those who have gone before – shaping and tending this branch of the Christian tree thatis so dear to us as Canadians.
The past two years have been particularly challenging: We have suffered the very harsh and real impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic, including the economic, racial, political and socialdivisions it has worsened at all levels of society. The confirmation of thousands of unmarkedgraves across the country, sparked by 215 graves found at the former site of Kamloops IndianResidential School (and then over 6,000+ and counting across the country), has renewed callsfor Canada to seriously address Indigenous justice concerns. We are on a continuing journey ofexamining the long and troubled relationship between Indigenous and non-IndigenousCanadians; the Indigenous church has not yet “accepted” the 1986 apology – in many ways weare still waiting for the rest of the church to make the necessary changes to live into thatapology. I believe this is still an area of misunderstanding for many in the church, and bearsfurther discussion as part of our denominational journey of repentance and healing. And Ibelieve that there is much the non-Indigenous church can learn from Indigenous peoples aspart of that journey.
So many of our traditional Indigenous cultures are deeply place-based, grounded in concepts that roughly translate to “the good living / the good life.” That good living is an activerelationship of reciprocation and respect for the earth our mother – a respect that is based onstriking balance and a differently oriented political and economic systems and stronger socialconnection. The Climate Emergency is not waiting for political systems to catch up. We haveelders who remind us that there were other ways of living, and youth demanding we reorientourselves to preserve any quality of life for their future. Those of us who make decisions about our elders and our youth have a moral obligation to take the climate emergency seriously andto call on our country to pivot in radical ways; ways that we know are possible due to the typesof policy changes and leadership we saw during the Second World War and the Apollo Missionin the US – and in our global and collective responses (as imperfect as they were) to Covid-19.
Our church is currently working to be a place of deep spirituality, bold discipleship, and daringjustice. All three of those are traditions deeply grounding our faith: prayer and awe at theMystery, living in the way of Jesus, and trying to seek structures and systems in society that would realize the world we believe a triune God calls us to co-create so that we might have lifeand have it in abundance. Traditional Indigenous ways of life are deeply spiritual, based onprotocols that govern our interactions with each other towards right action, and a commitmentto living in balance with the world and with each other. In many ways, we were traditionallyfocused on the present and the future in a way that could be life-giving for our collectivefutures. So much of western civilization is focused on tradition, on the past, on facts. Thosethings are important, but rather than history and story being based on timelines and definitionsof what is “true” or “fact” – history for Indigenous peoples is meant to teach us how to betogether in this moment and into the future. The concept of looking into the future sevengenerations to make sure we realize the full consequences of our actions today would requireus to make decisions differently in order to truly live with respect in creation and to create thatgood living for all.
As we continue to live into this newly restructured church and are still trying to find our bearings, many of us are still grieving what was. In particular, the process and outcomes ofrestructuring has left the Indigenous church adrift in many ways. The restructuring of thechurch (and the elimination of transfer & settlement before that) have also impacted the ruralchurch in challenging ways.
Can we pivot in a 3-year period and shed our colonial baggage, solving all of our societal, political, economic, or environmental problems? No. But we can live into our 2006 commitmentto each other to become an intercultural church. Being an intercultural church together meansthat we are radically committed to community, to granting each other dignity and listening toeach other in ways that transforms who each of us is and who we are together. It is heeding thebiblical call to “Fear not.” It is gathering when we fear there isn’t enough but realizing there arefishes and loaves among us. It is watching everyday events and realizing they are as miraculousas turning water into wine or seeing Jesus walk on water.
My vision for The United Church of Canada is that together we can work to continue to define who we are. To build new connections and rebuild old ones. To work towards social changethat sees a world cared for, and human dignity honoured. To walk together every day inrepentance and reconciliation. To march and fight and change unjust systems together. To pray together. To sing together. To discern together. Because truly we are not alone. We live inGod’s world.